Hi everyone! First, just want to say thanks to this amazing community of supportive people—I've learned so much from all of you on our first puppy journey.
Our 13-week Golden Retriever puppy is making good progress. She sleeps on her bed through the night as well as during the day in her play pen, is great with potty training, and is improving in her overall calmness. It feels like all the positive reinforcement methods we have tried are paying off!
One issue that I am seeing conflicting advice on is demand barking. She starting doing this more recently (maybe adolescence pushing boundaries?), and the worst is when I am cooking or when my wife and I are eating dinner or hanging out and we put her in her pen to settle. She won't settle and will keep barking and ask to be let out. (If we put her in there and go do our own thing, she settles much more easily.) We also tried having her settle on a mat next to the table so she can be closer to us, but then she barks at us for food (though she's been fed).
I've read the advice of ignoring them to teach them that barking won't get them what they want. On the other hand, I've also read that barking is self-reinforcing and that we should give her a job to do instead (e. g. "stay"). If we ask for a "down" or "stay," she does do it and stops barking… but only for 10-20 seconds. So, we are a bit stuck because we can either:
1) Keep asking for down and stay and give her a treat every 20 seconds, which seems unsustainable and unhealthy.
2) Ignore her barking, but I am not sure if that's the right thing to do.
I would love to hear what worked for you. Thank you all for your generous help!
submitted by /u/grassgrows-24
[link] [comments]