We got a bull terrier puppy from a breeder in early September. It was a dream of mine. I always wanted a bull terrier and waited my whole life to be on my own so I can get one. I grew up in a family that did not like dogs.
We adopted the puppy at 9 weeks old. He was perfect as soon as we brought him home. Would sleep all day, play while he was awake
We took him to puppy school, where he was paired up with other not fully vaccinated puppies to learn together and work on socializing. We have a big fenced in yard in an area near a dog park and he got to spend a lot of time in the yard meeting people and other dogs. He learned how to sit within a few minutes, he slept in his crate and learned to wait for his food. But then the biting started.
I never had a dog so I thought it was all normal puppy behavior. I tried to read all I could about it, so I started yelping, redirecting with a toy, disengaging, nothing worked. Every once in a while we would get a bite that was worse than the rest, seemingly unprompted.
The first couple bites there was no warning, just a snap and a bloody finger or lip. Each time we would get it, walk away and express our sadness to him. We never punished him, or yelled or got mean. We tried the best we could at positive reinforcement.
By the next month he started getting very angry and aggressive when his crate would lock. He would go in and out of his crate on his own all day. Took all his naps in his crate. Would wait in his crate for dinner. Every time he went in we gave him treats, a chew, toys. If we locked it, he would lose it. As soon as we let him out he would charge us. We stopped closing it all together and figured as long as he’s sleeping in it it’s fine. (The crate was located in the kitchen and we had a puppy gate keeping him in the kitchen. It’s the only area of the house with hardwood). A few times he would get angry if we walked into the kitchen, but it was rare. That would only happen once every week or two, but closing the crate was every single time.
He soon started biting a lot harder for different things. He loved being held, but he would try to bite if you were walking back to the kitchen. If he was cranky and you’re in the kitchen, he might bite if you open the fridge. He would bite at your hand if you opened the dryer. If you asked him to do a trick 3 times he would growl and snap at you.
When I tell people he would bite, everybody would say that’s what all puppies do, but he would attack us. I got bit on my jaw, my hand 2 times. My girlfriend got bit on the lip, he hand and arms and legs multiple times since she spent the most time with him. Majority of the bites I blamed on teething and him being a puppy, but some of them felt like he was trying to hurt us.
His episodes kept escalating till he would be trying to attack us for up to 2 minutes. He would stand on his hind legs, wrap his front legs around us and bite at our hips. He would pull and growl and snarl and keeping pulling and biting. Things like this would happen once every week or two. We felt like we were managing it during the down time until it would happen again.
2 days before Christmas while I was in the shower I heard the sound of him snarling again so I ran downstairs. My girlfriend was on the floor in the dining room putting a crate away and He broke through the gate to attack her. By the time I got downstairs her hand was in his mouth and he would not let go. I did the best I could to remain calm and tried to talk to him to get him to let go. We were both pleading with him. I took my towel off to throw in on his to distract him but while I did that, he bit a chunk of skin off my arm about the size of a half dollar. He went back and got her hand again and kept biting. I ended up ripping off his stocking from the wall and finding a bag of treats so I could throw them to the other side of the room. It worked, we were able to get away, but as soon as he finished he charged the gate again and tried to get through. When we went to our room he curled up into a ball and went right to sleep. He would always fall right asleep after one of his episodes, no matter the time of day.
We called the breeder immediately and she ended up taking him back, on Christmas Day. I cried for 3 days straight. I’ve never been more heartbroken in my life. When the breeder got to the house he was in a good mood. She asked if she could crate him to see his reaction and exactly what I thought would happen, happened. He went nuts. We kept him in there while we talked for about 10 minutes. He settled and laid down. As soon as she went to open the crate he freaked out again and charged her the second he could. He had to physically subdue him.
Everybody is telling me that I made the right decision but I can’t help but feel like I gave up too early, or there is something I could have done to fix him. I don’t want to believe he’s a bad dog at all. I love him with my whole heart, forever. He’s my first dog and I can’t believe it ended like this, so quickly. Everybody is telling me that that is not how a “normal” dog acts.
Does it sound like there was anything I could have done?
Does it sound like it could possibly be my fault?
Could a behaviorist help fix him?
If they could, would it even be a good and relaxing life for all of us if everybody is constantly scared of triggering an episode?
I can’t stop thinking about it and want to believe it’s not his fault, it’s just the way his brain is wired
That is also the story of the worst Christmas of my life.